What remains can hardly be justified from a straightforward reading of the koran or the hadith. In other words, the democracy that western nations have enjoyed is now appearing in the middle east. Many critics in the west decry the humans rights abuses and autocratic government of many gulf countries as the result of islams precepts. They dictate in no uncertain terms how their adherents should live. Excluding the period of the rightly guided caliphs which consisted of a democratic system of governance, the rest of the time it was dynasties that ruled muslim lands.
The politically correct revisionist liberal narrative insisting that islam is a religion like any other can only exist in subjective reality. The interaction of political islam with democracy arab american. Jun 08, 2016 it should not be a mystery whether islam is compatible with democracy or not. According to some commentators, these protests reflect a relatively new push for democracy by the arab peoples. This argument is based on one theoretical assumption that democracy and shura islam are not compatible and one empirical assumption that muslims strongly adhere to islamic principles. Sep 30, 20 true khilafat compatible with democracy. Some extend the argument to affirm that under the conditions of the contemporary world, democracy can be considered a requirement of islam. By doing so, it encompasses the wide range of arguments that scholars have made on the issue and shows clearly what makes it possible for islam and democracy to be. Political science throughout its history, islam has been marked by two trends. Toward new democratic imaginaries istanbul seminars on islam. For an indepth study by a nonmuslim of how islam has been portrayed in the western literature, see norman daniel, islam and the west. Islam and democracy eliane ursula ettmueller abstract.
According to websters dictionary, democracy is a form of government in which supreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly by them. Book of emaan ibn taymiyah, faith in predestination, alwala walbara and more. Voll georgetown university abstract the relationship between islam and democracy is a hotly debated topic. In considering the compatibility of islam and democracy, muqtedar khan noted, one.
Western democracy for them is part of the hated west, and that hatred is central to the ideas by which they define themselves, as in the past the free world defined itself first against nazism and. But there are practical political rather than philosophical reasons for the lack of democracy in muslim societies. Yet, from an academic standpoint, it is the assertive form of secularism only which has that effect 208. Examination of this fear is the strength of fatima mernissis 1992 book about the arabislamic world, published shortly after the. It contains principles that are based on the fundamental principles of islam and islamic morals of right and wrong. Many critics in the west decry the humans rights abuses and autocratic government of many gulf countries as the result of islam s precepts. Thus the absence of democracy in muslim countries is by means on account of islamic teachings or incompatibility of democracy with islam but due to host of factors political, historical and cultural. A living democracy should contain the constitutional and legal means to seriously disagree, yet theocratic states seem especially fearful of such freedom of debate. Many prominent islamic intellectuals and groups, however, argue that islam and democracy are compatible. Islam and democracy muslim world residents see no conflict between religious principles and democratic values by dalia mogahed, executive director, the gallup center for muslim studies islam in politics has been asserted in many countries in the muslim world through democratic elections. Professor suleiman obser ved that this was a difficult question to answer. The national interest at the dawn of the socalled arab spring in 2011, diplomats, politicians, and intellectuals debated a fresh question. Biographies of the rightlyguided caliphs, ar raheeq al makhtum, stories of the prophets.
And surely excellent is that with which allah admonishes you. According to most recent rankings by freedom house, a respected nongovernmental organization that monitors global democratic development, over half of the global muslim population about 800 million is located in countries that are listed as free or partly. Muslim societies had monarchs ruling them for a very long period, stretching about a thousand years. Sudan and morocco in a comparative perspective by waleed mousa august 2005 chair. Fai emphasized that islam, as a growing force in the world, is not a threat in its ideal form and is particularly compatible with western ideals of freedom and democracy. Examination of this fear is the strength of fatima mernissis 1992 book about the arabislamic world, published shortly after the end of the first gulf war. Islam is compatible to democracy in the sense that it also has enormous mechanisms that enable it emphasize the rule of law. Reformminded muslims who prefer to ignore all of this instead point to quran 42. May 28, 2016 islam is not compatible with democracy. Child education in islam, the rights of children in islam, a message to every youth. Trying to prove that islam is compatible with democracy, many muslims are forced to twist existing islamic concepts so that they cease to retain their original meaning. Where, for example, has islam proven to be compatible with democracy.
This move became a crucial event in the history of islam and came to be known as hijra. Pdf on nov 29, 2015, robert brym and others published are islam and democracy compatible. Congress, the white house has promised to protect turkeys. The quran and modern science compatible or incompatible. Download sahih muslim download sahih muslim hadith collection. An empirical analysis of the repression of religion, 198020. Assertive secularism can under certain conditions pasha, 1044 rahman, 2016, 64 206. There is also a more worrying aspect to all this, too. Islam s precepts are not predicated on choice personal or otherwise. Although turkey selected a sanctioned chinese firm to coproduce an antimissile system over the objections of nato and the u. All you have to do is look at the islamic sources or call any imam and pretend to be impressed that islam does not. Democracy building remains an uphill struggle in most muslim countries. The explanation of why so many muslim countries are not democratic has more to do with historical, political, cultural, and economic factors than with religious ones. The first trend is a literalist tradition, which considers the sharia laws as expounded in the medieval manuals.
A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. This is not to say that individual muslims cannot immigrate to western countries with complete success. Islams precepts are not predicated on choice personal or otherwise. Many people were impressed by verses of the quran and converted to islam out of their free will. Islam and democracy it is election season in america and time to look at one the of the dhimmis favorite mythsthe democratization. True khilafat compatible with democracy the muslim times. It is in the interest of the world, capitalists and the poor to invest.
The question whether democracy is compatible with islam has a. Political islam and democracy in the muslim world lynne rienner. The question of the compatibility of islam and democracy has persisted for generations. Rejection some traditionalists and islamists totally reject democracy as a foreign infidel import that has no place in islam. When one asks whether islam is compatible with democracy, one needs to analyze the definition of democracy. Election laws must assure free and honest elections while ensuring the. Usually the disagreements are expressed in a standard form. Slowly but surely, the evidence is coming in, and it is that islam is incompatible with democracy and civil society. Gods sovereignty precludes any sovereignty of man in any form. This paper proposes a short apprehension of the reflections of one of the most important progressive islamic scholars, the egyptian theologian ali abderraziq. Given the wests exposure to the middle east over the past decade and a half, there has been a lot of dialogue over whether or not islam is compatible with democracy. This is not to say that an islamic society would look like an american representative democracy, but neither do any of the socialist democracies or monarchies found. Also recruited to this end is an oftrepeated hadith that has muhammad saying, my community will never agree on an.
Analysing the compatibility of islam and democracy politics essay. The implicit explanation for this delay, for some, is that most arabs are muslim and islam is not compatible with democracy. Parliament being sovereign does not permit it free rein. Islam is compatible with western ideals of freedom and democracy. Sep 22, 2016 is political islam compatible with democracy. The compatibility of islam and democracy has become one of the main questions of concern in.
This book is dedicated to those who openmindedly seek knowledge wherever it is. Islam and modernity some scholars have argued that christianity and judaism have essentially come to terms with modernity, as represented by western pluralistic societies such as the united states, and dont view modernity as a. Shadi hamid, author of islamic exceptionalism, argues many muslims support a religiousdominated government, but that doesnt equal violence. All you have to do is look at the islamic sources or call any imam and pretend to. The imperialist powers, firstly of europe and then those of united states also play their own role. An islamic democracy in iraq will signal to the muslim world that the u. Even with the islamic schisms of sunnis, shias, alawites, salafids, wahhabis, druze and so many others, all have one quality in common. It focuses on his work about islam and the fundamentals of power, published in 1925. However, since the growing popularity of islam jeopardized muhammads and his disciples lives, the entire community moved from mecca to medina circa 622 ce. In this form, the debaters definitions of islam and democracy determine the conclusions arrived at. This notion was compatible with that of part of the egyptian elite, who wanted to run. Indeed, allah commands you to make over the trusts to those entitled to them, and that, when you judge between men, you judge with justice. There are some major misconceptions about this issue.
Download sahih muslim download sahih muslim hadith. In addition, the godgiven sovereignty of 4 for instance, a number of influential academics in the united states such as eliot cohen of johns hopkins university and kenneth adelman of the defense departments defense policy board have suggested that islam is essentially intolerant, expansionist, and violent. It should not be a mystery whether islam is compatible with democracy or not. Ever since the dawn of human life on this planet, man has always sought to understand nature, his own place in the scheme of creation and the purpose of life itself. Ghannouchi makes a case for the full compatibility of islam and democracy, emphasizing islams lack of hierarchy, support for pluralism, and. Jun 15, 2016 given the wests exposure to the middle east over the past decade and a half, there has been a lot of dialogue over whether or not islam is compatible with democracy.
757 405 1502 688 227 639 1514 458 1085 882 836 102 1442 665 1289 569 270 1438 245 880 1095 874 1544 881 1310 572 1042 1543 1215 1352 1495 725 663 356 421 894 1012 933 53 1420